We often guide homeowners through the decision between insert window replacement and full frame window replacement. Both options have their merits – we’ll explore the key differences and highlight why a full frame replacement, installed in the rough opening, can offer superior benefits for your home.

Before-After for Insert Window

Before-After for Full-Frame Window

What is Insert Window Replacement?

Insert window replacement involves fitting a new window into the existing window frame. The old window sash is removed, but the original frame remains intact. A new window unit, custom-sized to fit the existing opening, is then installed. This method is often quicker and less invasive, making it a popular choice for homeowners looking for a straightforward, cost-effective solution.

Advantages of Insert Window Replacement:

• • Less Disruption: Since the existing frame stays in place, there’s minimal disturbance to your home’s interior and exterior.
  • Lower Cost: Insert replacements typically require less labor and material, making them more budget-friendly.
  • Faster Installation: The process is often completed quickly due to less disruption.

Drawbacks of Insert Window Replacement:

• • Limited Glass Area: The new window fits within the existing frame, which can greatly reduce the visible glass area.
  • Proper Insulation: No ability to properly insulate the window opening
  • Frame Condition Dependency: If the existing frame is damaged, rotten, warped, or poorly insulated, issues may persist after installation.
  • No Opportunity for Structural Upgrades: Insert replacements don’t allow for changes to the window’s size, style, or surrounding millwork.

What is Full Frame Window Replacement?

Full frame window replacement involves removing the entire existing window, including the frame, down to the rough opening (studs) in the wall. A new window, complete with a new frame, is then installed and secured directly into the rough opening. This method is more involved but offers significant long-term benefits, especially when paired with a high-quality window like Restorations Windows.

Advantages of Full Frame Window Replacement:

1. Maximizing Glass Area
With a full frame replacement, you’re not constrained by the size of the existing frame. This allows for a larger window unit, increasing the visible glass area. More glass means more natural light, enhanced views, and a brighter, more inviting home interior. Restorations Windows from Sunrise are designed to optimize glass space while maintaining energy efficiency, making them an excellent choice for homeowners looking to elevate their home’s aesthetic and functionality.

2. Proper Insulation for Energy Efficiency
One of the standout benefits of full frame replacement is the opportunity to address insulation issues in the rough opening. At THEBCO, we ensure the window is properly sealed and insulated during installation, reducing air leaks and improving energy efficiency. This is especially critical in Sun Prairie, WI, where harsh winters demand windows that can keep your home warm and reduce energy bills. Restorations Windows feature advanced insulation technologies, such as Low-E glass and multi-chambered frames, which complement the enhanced insulation of a full frame installation.

3. Opportunity to Upgrade Interior Millwork
A full frame replacement opens the door to refreshing or upgrading the interior millwork surrounding your windows. Many homeowners have chosen to replace old golden oak trim with painted millwork to give a complete transformation. Our team at THEBCO can work with you to choose millwork that complements your home’s style, adding value and charm to your living space.

4. Addressing Structural Issues
Full frame replacement allows us to inspect and repair any damage in the rough opening, such as wood rot, water infiltration, or structural weaknesses. This ensures your new window is installed in a sound, secure environment, extending its lifespan and performance. With Restorations Windows, you get durable, weather-resistant materials that stand up to Wisconsin’s climate.

5. Customization and Flexibility
Unlike insert replacements, full frame replacements allow you to change the window’s size, shape, or style. Want to replace a small window with a larger picture window or switch to a different operating style, like a casement or double-hung? Full frame replacement makes it possible, giving you the freedom to reimagine your home’s look and functionality.

Drawbacks of Full Frame Window Replacement:

• Cost: The process requires more labor and materials, which can increase upfront costs.
• Installation Time: Full frame replacements can take longer than insert replacements due to the scope of the project.

Why Choose Full Frame Replacement with THEBCO?
At THEBCO Windows, Doors and Siding, we believe full frame window replacement is often the best choice for homeowners who want to maximize their investment. By installing Restorations Windows in the rough opening, you’re not just replacing a window—you’re upgrading your home’s energy efficiency, aesthetic appeal, and long-term value. Here’s why partnering with us makes a difference:

• Expert Installation: Our skilled team in Madison, WI, ensures precise installation, paying close attention to insulation, sealing, and structural integrity.
• High-Quality Products: Restorations Windows are known for their durability, energy efficiency, and stylish designs, making them a perfect fit for full frame replacements.
• Custom Solutions: We work closely with you to customize window sizes, styles, and interior millwork to match your vision.
• Local Expertise: As a Madison-based company, we understand the unique challenges of Wisconsin’s climate and tailor our installations to withstand the elements.

Which Option is Right for You?
Choosing between insert and full frame window replacement depends on your goals, budget, and the condition of your existing windows. If your current window frames are in good shape and you’re looking for a quick, cost-effective solution, insert replacement might be the way to go. However, if you want to maximize glass area, improve insulation, address structural issues, or upgrade your home’s interior millwork, full frame replacement is the superior choice.

At THEBCO Windows, Doors and Siding, we’re here to help you make an informed decision. Contact us today for a consultation, and let us show you how new windows or doors could transform your home. Call us at 608-249-2905 or visit www.THEBCO.com to schedule your appointment!